להלן הצעתי לתשובה למתיו.
חשוב לכתב גם את חיה גרוס כפי שהוא עשה.
Dear Matt,
Regarding the additional points you raise, allow me to clarify the following:
·
After further clarification from Ilana, It will not be necessary to prepare a model class for level 1, nor to be especially available
to her for routine advice.
·
As I wrote in my previous message, we would like you to prepare a recommended "model" lesson for both levels 2 and 3. I did
not differentiate between them as I believe it should be a fairly similar model class in terms of structure, with some modifications in terms of content. I do believe that the hours allocated for that, given that this is not required for level 1, should suffice.
I include in that any routine advice that those 2 instructors may need.
·
Regarding the potential work with the Mabal instructors, I believe this should be included in the preparation time for your classes.
Right now we are talking about 3 instructors (Merav included). The other two have not given a final answer, as they would like to see how the first one goes. What is required is from them is to suggest a topic and a relevant piece to read before the class,
and for you to tell them how they will be integrated in part/all the time allocated for that class.
As a general comment I would note that given various budgetary constraints, and the fact we need to pay to 4 instructors, we are really not in a position to allocate
more than 80 hours for your important part in this project. We will have to find the right balance to get the most out of this limited amount we have. I hope for your understanding and good cooperation in this regard.
Best regards,
Yossi
From: matt cohen [mailto:mcohen71@gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, September 05, 2020 10:40 PM
To: yossib@univ.haifa.ac.il
Cc: Merav Zafari-Odiz <Merav@mail.gov.il>; Matan Or <OrMatan@mail.gov.il>; tmalul@univ.haifa.ac.il; hgross@univ.haifa.ac.il
Subject: Re: MABAL - EMI/ EFL Courses
Hi Yossi,
I appreciate your clarification and would like to ask if the following points should be considered outside
the scope of my position.
Additionally, I would ask for the hours needed to coordinate with the MABAL instructors and plan lessons for the level 4 students to be considered.
With the courses beginning soon, I do look forward to adapting the new framework as quickly as possible.
Shavu'a Tov,
Matt
On Sat, Sep 5, 2020 at 12:48 PM
yossib@univ.haifa.ac.il <yossib@univ.haifa.ac.il> wrote:
Dear Matthew,
Thank you for sending a detailed explanation about your request.
After reviewing it, I must admit that I am afraid there has been miscommunication on our part about our needs, and the way we would like to go about this new "experiment" of teaching English in Mabal.
Unlike things are normally done in the university context, our basic intention is to allow the participants an opportunity to practice a fairly simple discourse in English, and improve their English speaking skills a bit. The College commander has set the rationale for the English sessions as improving the capability of the participants to converse in English or listen to a lecture in English. Given the heterogeneity of the class , and with your kind professional assistance, we divided the participants into four groups, as we would like to give each group instruction at its appropriate level.
What we had in mind for the classes themselves (in particular for levels 2-4) is that the participants and the instructors will carry on conversations over a simple text together (such as an article from a newspaper), and while doing so will learn some relevant vocabulary and grammar. We obviously have no intention to certify them for any particular level as we do at the university. This is also why we took instructors who are not professional English teachers , but are experienced translators who are also proficient in the learning materials at Mabal.
We do believe that it will be very useful if the instructors, particularly for levels 2-3, can get from you some guidance on how to best structure the class, and some ideas on what they can actually teach in each session. We will then leave it to them to finally decide how they actually build and exercise their sessions. There is also no need in our view for too close supervision, or for you "to inspect" classes, because this is not a strict academic instruction toward a certification.
For the 1st level, we will generally leave it to the instructor to do the work, unless she asks for further guidance, as she has been teaching English for seniors for years. But preparing a suggested "model class" will also be helpful.
For the 4th level group that you will lead, we trust that you will do a great job in the 6 sessions we have allocated to this group, with the assistance of some of our English speaking instructors at Mabal.
To sum up what is required from you according to our needs:
- Teaching 6 sessions of one hour and 15 minutes each for the highest level.
- Suggesting a "model" class for each session for levels 2-3 in terms of structure, vocabulary and grammar to be taught. We generally believe that it will fairly similar work for these 2 levels.
- Preparing a "model class" and giving routine advice, if necessary, for the 1st level.
On top of that of course we will pay you for the important work you have done so far in the screening and preparation stage.
Quantifying the above, we came up with the following breakdown:
- Direct teaching - 12 academic hours
- Preparation of a "model class" for each group - 4 hours for each of the 12 sessions = 48
- Screening and preparatory process - 19 hours
Total - 80 hours
I hope this clarifies things, and I apologize for our part in coordinating mutual expectations at an earlier stage.
With best wishes and hope for fruitful cooperation
Yossi
From: matt cohen <mcohen71@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, September 4, 2020 3:59 PM
To: יוסי בן-ארצי <yossib@univ.haifa.ac.il>
Subject: MABAL - EMI/ EFL Courses
Hi Yossi,
Thank you for your call yesterday. Detailed below is a rationale for the 200 hours requested in the contact you were sent as well as other pertinent details. This does not include the hours I will be teaching, the time I have spent interviewing students, or the various meetings I have had with the Mabal regarding their expectations. Also, note that after the contract had been sent to you, the Mabal requested a 4th class and teacher, meaning an additional 12 hours of instruction, materials, etc.
If there is anything else you might need, please let me know..
Have a great weekend.
Best,
Matt
Hours and Justification
- 200 hours and 15% for every 20 hours of instruction for:
- preparing a curriculum and syllabi
- preparing lesson plans, classroom materials, and additional class materials
- supervising, meeting, preparing, and observing teachers to assure quality of the program
- creating and adapting the curriculum and materials to various student/ teacher needs
- creating an acceptable, organized program
Program Structure:
- 75 minutes of frontal teaching per meeting
- 42 total meetings across 4 levels of instruction
- 4 teachers
- Level 1: English as a Foreign Language Course (EFL) - 12 meetings
- Level 2: English-Medium Instruction Courses (EMI) - 12 meetings
- Level 3: EMI Course - 12 meetings
- Level 4: EMI Course w/ guest presentations - 6 meetings (this is the course that I will be instructing)
Classes and Levels:
- All classes require:
- a general curriculum and syllabi
- daily lesson plans customized to students
- daily lesson plans adapted to teachers
- additional resources, activities, grammar, and, general language exercises
- Level 1: Novice Low (approx CEFR: 0-A1) - focused on fluency and accuracy
- Students require basic grammar and fluency training within a communicative class framework
- Level 2 Intermediate low to Intermediate Mid (approx CEFR: A2-B1.1) - focused on topic awareness and discussion
- Students require topic oriented classes and communicative skills building as well as novice high to intermediate language skills
- Level 3: Intermediate high to Advanced mid (approx CEFR: B1.2-B2.2) - focused on topic development discussion
- Students require topic oriented classes and advanced communicative skills building as well as intermediate to low advanced language skills
- Level 4: Advanced high to Superior (approx CEFR: C1-C2) - focused on discussion and organization
- Students require topic oriented discussions and critical analyses of subject matter with a secondary focus on advanced language skills